Inline concentration monitoring for PAG polymer quenchants

Heat treatment · Metalworking

Inline refractometric concentration of water-soluble polymer (PAG) quenchants: the handheld spot check made continuous. The page sets out three traps — dissolved contamination that inflates the reading, degradation the refractive index does not show, and inverse solubility that decides where the probe goes — and where kinematic viscosity and cooling curves must take over.

Applicable industries
Inline concentration monitoring for PAG polymer quenchants

PISONICS

PS7110 Series

Inline Process Refractometer

Critical angle · thin-layer interface · indifferent to colour and turbidity

Inline Concentration Monitoring for PAG Polymer Quenchants

—— Induction hardening · through hardening · quench-tank circulation ——

【Measured: quenchant concentration (%) / refractive index nD】

Inline concentration monitoring for PAG polymer quenchants

1. Process background

The cooling rate of a water-soluble polymer quenchant (mostly polyalkylene glycol, PAG) is set mainly by its concentration: too low and cooling is too fast, raising residual stress and distortion and, at worst, cracking; too high and cooling is too slow, risking low hardness.

And concentration drifts by nature: evaporation concentrates it, drag-out on the parts depletes it, and make-up adds its own error. The usual shop-floor practice is to read Brix on a handheld refractometer, multiply by the supplier's refractometer factor, and check against kinematic viscosity — which tells you refractometry is already the method on this duty. What the PS7110 does is make the same quantity continuous: the reading is on the same basis as the handheld, directly comparable, and it can go to a PLC to close the make-up loop.

2. Three traps for a refractometer on quenchant

1. The factor drifts with contamination. Refractive index does not know where it comes from: inorganic salts from hard water, dragged-in cleaners or other water-soluble fluids, and oil all raise the reading once dissolved, so the factor usually goes down. Left uncorrected, the displayed concentration reads higher than the actual polymer concentration — the make-up loop adds too little, the real concentration keeps falling, and low concentration is exactly the cracking risk. Carbon fines and most insoluble solids have little effect.

2. Degradation is invisible. Over long service the polymer degrades and the cooling behaviour changes, but the refractometer reading may not show it. Cooling characteristics are checked by cooling-curve testing (ASTM D6482) on the supplier's schedule; ASTM D6666 lists what to evaluate.

3. Inverse solubility decides where the probe goes. PAG comes out of solution at higher temperature — that is how it forms a film on the hot part and controls cooling. So the probe must not sit near the quench zone, and the bath must stay below its cloud point; once the liquid separates into two phases the refractometer reading means nothing.

3. What it can and cannot do

It can:

  • Track concentration drift continuously — evaporation, drag-out and make-up error all become visible
  • Measure the same quantity as the handheld refractometer, so the readings are directly comparable
  • Send 4–20 mA and RS485 (Modbus RTU) to a PLC to close the automatic make-up loop

It cannot (stated here so nobody buys the wrong thing):

  • Tell polymer from dissolved contaminants — check against kinematic viscosity (ASTM D445) periodically and correct the factor
  • See polymer degradation — that needs cooling-curve testing
  • Measure pH or bacteria — measure those separately; they do not show in the refractive index
  • Run unfiltered on a bath carrying scale and grit — abrasive particles must be removed upstream; the detection window is a wear part

4. Selecting the PS7110

GradePrismProcess temp.RI rangeFactory scaleFits
PS7110-AHigh-strength optical glass0–60 °C1.33299–1.465100–70 %BrixCooler baths with a modest range
PS7110-BSapphire0–70 °C1.33299–1.517820–90 %BrixDefault for most quench tanks (a PAG bath has to run below its cloud point anyway)
PS7110-CSapphire−10–100 °C1.33299–1.570410–100 %BrixWarmer baths, or lines that may fall below 0 °C in winter

Put the probe on a bypass from the quench-tank circulation pump discharge, after the filter and after the cooler; not in the quench zone and not next to the parts in the tank.

General specification:

ItemSpecification (data sheet Rev. B)
Measured valueRefractive index nD; converted to concentration by a scale (%Brix, or a wt% scale built for the medium)
AccuracyRI ±0.0001; Brix ±0.1 %; temperature ±0.5 °C
ResolutionRI 0.00001; Brix 0.01 %; temperature 0.1 °C
Measuring interval2–60 s, settable
Pressure ratingDetection surface ≤ 1.5 MPa
Cleaning temperature0–120 °C, CIP / SIP capable
Wetted materialsSS316L + prism; Hastelloy, titanium or tantalum optional on grades B / C
Process connectionClamp (Ø77.5 mm ferrule); custom tee / cross, cross in DN25 / 50 / 65 / 80
Outputs4–20 mA; RS485 (Modbus RTU)
Power / ambientDC 24 V; −10 to 70 °C
Hazardous areaEx ia IIC T6 Ga (intrinsically safe)

5. Building the scale

The scale belongs to your quenchant product: start from the supplier's refractometer factor at commissioning, then correct it with the concentration found by kinematic viscosity (ASTM D445); check it again after a product change, a change in make-up water, or a contamination event. On site the PS7110 supports RI calibration, self-built models from laboratory samples and multi-point temperature compensation, so the factor is corrected without returning the instrument.

6. Installation and upkeep

  • Never mount the detection face pointing down — deposits build up, and a deposit does not raise a fault; it shows only as a slow one-way drift
  • On a vertical line the flow must be upward — a downcomer drains when the pump stops, the prism is no longer wetted and the reading means nothing
  • On a horizontal line insert from below (face up) or from the side (face vertical); inserting from the top is not allowed
  • Mount on a bypass of the circulation loop, with a valve at each end so it can be isolated
  • Filter upstream: scale, grit and other abrasive particles must be removed
  • Do not sample from the surface layer of floating oil and foam: oil films the prism; place the probe in the full-bore pump discharge
  • Decide the cleaning at design stage — ultrasonic or high-pressure flushing units are available

7. Before you order

  • Quenchant brand and grade, and the supplier's refractometer factor.
  • Target concentration and allowed band.
  • Bath temperature range, and the product's cloud point.
  • Likely contamination sources: hard water, cleaners, carried-over cutting fluid, oil, salts.
  • Filtration fineness and how much grit the bath carries.
  • Bypass line size and connection type.
  • Number of measuring points: one per tank, or several tanks.

What this page is: a method and selection note, not a case study. The PS7110 has no publishable installed data in this industry yet, so there are no unit counts, saving percentages or payback periods here — we do not invent those. The numbers on the page are of two kinds only: the instrument's own specification, and published properties and standards, plus order-of-magnitude estimates derived from them.

Conclusion

PISONICS covers six principle families (ultrasonic, tuning fork, Coriolis, optical, microwave, differential pressure) for inline density and concentration. Quenchant, like cutting fluid, is already measured by refractometry on the shop floor; going inline turns a spot check into a continuous reading — but it does not replace the viscosity check or the cooling curve. Further reading: cutting fluid and coolant ratio monitoring, ethylene / propylene glycol concentration monitoring, Optical concentration meter principle.

FAQ

The inline reading looked normal, yet quenched parts cracked — what could it be?

Check contamination first. Refractive index does not know where it comes from: salts from hard water, dragged-in cleaners, other water-soluble fluids and oil all raise the reading once dissolved. If the factor is not corrected, the displayed concentration reads higher than the actual polymer concentration, the make-up loop adds too little and the real concentration keeps falling — and low concentration, hence fast cooling, is the classic cause of cracking.

What to do: measure concentration once by kinematic viscosity (ASTM D445) and correct the factor to it; and run the cooling-curve test (ASTM D6482) on the supplier's schedule to rule out polymer degradation.

How often should a quenchant's refractometer factor be checked?

Set the frequency with your supplier; it depends on how fast the bath picks up contamination — very clean systems see little change in the factor, heavily contaminated ones a lot. Check it at once, outside the schedule, after a change of quenchant product, a change in make-up water, a large carry-in of cleaner, cutting fluid or oil, or a systematic offset between the inline reading and the viscosity or handheld result.

The check is a correction of the factor to the concentration found by kinematic viscosity (ASTM D445); the PS7110 can be re-modelled on site from laboratory samples, without returning it to the factory.

Can the refractometer probe go straight into the quench tank, next to the parts?

Not recommended. PAG quenchants have inverse solubility: as temperature rises the polymer comes out of solution, which is how it forms a film on the hot part and controls cooling. Liquid near the quench zone may be in that separated state, and the refractometer reading then means nothing; the tank also carries floating oil, foam and scale.

Mount it on a bypass from the circulation pump discharge, after the filter and the cooler, full-bore, detection face not pointing down, with a valve at each end so it can be isolated.

Does the PS7110 prism need cleaning, and how often should it be checked?

A clean prism face is the single precondition for a trustworthy reading. Coating, scale, crystals or abrasion change the reading directly, and the instrument does NOT raise a fault when they do — it shows up as a slow one-way drift on an unusually smooth curve. So the cleaning strategy belongs in the design, not in a response to a reading that has already drifted. The prism material depends on the variant: high-strength optical glass on the A, sapphire on the B and C. For media that coat or crystallise, the PS7110-CL1 ultrasonic cleaning unit keeps the face clean continuously and the PS7110-CL2 high-pressure flushing unit flushes it periodically; sanitary processes can use CIP and SIP directly, with a cleaning temperature range of −30 to 120 °C. Where the medium can carry grit or abrasive particles, filter them out upstream or the detection window will be worn away. Putting "look at the face" into the routine inspection is worth more than any coefficient correction applied afterwards; the sensor status diagnostics help, but they do not replace looking.